How to Make a Homemade Peanut Butter Cup

I used a small ceramic ramekin (Target) for easier access to the good stuff, but you can use a mug or another small microwave-safe dish. I listed specific measurements here, but this is a forgiving recipe. Go for more of one ingredient to better suit your peanut butter-to-chocolate ratio preference. Made just like the instructions, I found the peanut butter cup super creamy, sweet, and oh-so-delicious. Considering how simple it is to make, I’ll definitely make this again. Keep this amazing flavor combination going in your next baking session by heading over to this recipe gallery dedicated to all things chocolate and peanut butter. Start with BHG classic revel bars or give your chocolate chip cookies a nutty upgrade.